PPSA: when the grantor registers a security interest…over itself
It is not uncommon for a lender, when completing it’s due diligence process, to come across situations where a proposed borrower has registered a security interest on the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR) over itself. Often leaving the lender perplexed, it must decide how to deal with the security interest (i.e. does it need to ensure the security interest is discharged so that the lender will rank ahead? or is this not necessary in circumstances where the registration is over itself?).
In the matter of Macquarie Leasing Pty Ltd v DEQMO Pty Ltd  NSWSC 1466, Rein J provided some insight into this issue. This matter dealt with a situation where DEQMO Pty Ltd (DEQMO) claimed to grant a security interest to itself.
At  Rein J states:
There are a number of reasons why DEQMO’s claimed interest can be seen not to be a valid claim:
(1) The claimed interest is one given by DEQMO to DEQMO. A person or company cannot give a security interest to itself: s 12 [of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009] which defines “security interest” as:
an interest in personal property provided for by a transaction that, in substance, secures payment or performance of an obligation (without regard to the form of the transaction or the identity of the person who has title to the property).
Rein J relevantly states that neither this requirement (nor the further requirements set out in subsection 12(3)) can be satisfied by an interest given by DEQMO to itself.
This case provides some comfort to lenders who come across situations where a borrower has registered a security interest on the PPSR over itself. However, best practice will always be to ensure that any prior ranking security interests, questionable or not, are discharged in circumstances where the lender requires a prior ranking position.
For more information, contact ERA Legal.
- ERA Legal helps a favoured return (part 2)
- May the enforcement be with you: The State Debt Recovery Act 2018 (NSW)
- Trust your limitations: Time limits for bringing proceedings for breach of fiduciary obligations
- A little or a Lot: costs orders in proceedings involving Owners Corporations
- Preliminary discovery: not enough information to commence a proceeding?
- Litigation Funding: What the court will consider when determining an application under section 477(2B)
- PPSA: when the grantor registers a security interest...over itself
- Unfair Contracts regime enforced by Federal Court
- PPSA - the 20 business day rule: when will the court grant an extension of time to register?
- Voidable transactions - the one who got delay